Tag: medically assisted death

31 Oct

In the News: Medical Assistance in Dying for Persons with Dementia

Kira Domratchev In the News Tags: , , 0 Comments

As many of us know, the federal government’s legislation on medical assistance in dying (“MAID”) – Bill C-14 – was passed on June 17, 2016.

Only physicians and nurse practitioners (in certain provinces) are permitted to provide MAID in two ways:

1) directly administer the substance that causes death (e.g. an injection of a drug); or

2) provide or prescribe a drug that is self-administered to cause death.

In order to be eligible for MAID, one must meet all of the following criteria:

  • be eligible for publicly-funded health services in Canada;
  • be at least 18 years of age and capable of making their own health care decisions [emphasis added];
  • have a grievous or irremediable medical condition;
  • make a voluntary request for MAID; and
  • give consent to receive MAID after being provided with all of the information necessary to make the decision.

For more information on MAID, please see the Government of Canada’s webpage on “Medical Assistance in Dying”.

Dr. Stefanie Green, in a recent British Columbia case, said that a person with dementia who meets the criteria, should be eligible for MAID, despite the previously widespread assumption that persons with dementia could not meet the eligibility requirements.

Mr. Gayle Garlock became one of the first Canadians with a dementia diagnosis publicly reported to have received MAID. The key issue in deciding whether a person is eligible for MAID, particularly in the case of a person with dementia, is asking whether they have the mental capacity for informed consent, intolerable suffering and a foreseeable death.

In Mr. Garlock’s case, he was diagnosed with Lewy body dementia in 2014, when he was 70 years old. According to Mr. Garlock’s wife, one of the losses that he would define as “intolerable suffering” was being unable to read.

By the spring of 2019, Mr. Garlock’s condition had deteriorated such that his mental processing had slowed and he struggled in conversation. Dr. Green, determined that he still knew what was going on around him and with him and that he understood that he had dementia and that it had progressed. His MAID application was approved on May 9, 2019. Mr. Garlock passed away peacefully with his wife and sons at his bedside.

According to Dr. Green, “This is not an expansion of our law…This is a maturing of the understanding of what we’re doing”.

This is important news to those persons suffering with dementia but is also a reminder to the medical community of the importance of approaching each case individually and carefully, particularly where a patient’s capacity may be in question.

To learn more about Mr. Garlock’s story, please see CBC’s recent article here.

Thanks for reading!

Kira Domratchev

Find this blog interesting? Please consider these other related posts:

Achieving Medically Assisted Death

Assisted dying – follow the rules and you’ll be fine

An Update on Medical Assistance in Dying

30 Dec

Proposed New Legislation on Physician-Assisted Death

Suzana Popovic-Montag Ethical Issues, Health / Medical, In the News Tags: , , , 0 Comments

The issue of medically assisted death attracted a lot of attention in 2016. We blogged on the topic several times.

The federal Bill C-14, An Act to amend the Criminal Code and to make related amendments to other Acts (medical assistance in dying) received Royal Assent in June 2016. The federal legislation has been criticized for being too restrictive. The British Columbia Civil Liberties Association has indicated it plans to challenge the constitutionality of the federal legislation.

The government of Ontario recently proposed legislation to complement the federal legislation. Some highlights of the proposed Medical Assistance in Dying Statute Law Amendment Act include:

  • Patients must be competent adults over the age of 18 and suffer from incurable conditions or face a reasonably foreseeable natural death to qualify for physician-assisted death.
  • All physician-assisted deaths must be reported to the Coroner, who may then choose whether or not to investigate the death.
  • Physicians and nurse practitioners are not liable for any act or omission made in good faith in performing a medically-assisted death.
  • Insurance and workplace compensation benefits cannot be denied to people for choosing medically assisted death.

The Medical Assistance in Dying Statute Law Amendment Act has only passed the first reading stage and may change as it is subject to second and third readings. The provincial legislature will not debate the bill again until February, when the legislature reconvenes after winter break.

Thank you for reading.

Suzana Popovic-Montag

Other articles you might enjoy:

An Update Regarding Physician-Assisted Death

Assisted Dying – Only the Beginning?

The First Decision Regarding Physician-Assisted Death in Ontario


Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.