A beneficiary’s continued occupation of Estate property can create a difficult problem for an Estate Trustee attempting to complete the administration of an Estate, particularly where the property must be sold. In The Estate of Sean Craddock et al. v. Daviau, 2026 ONSC 4881, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice considered what happens when a beneficiary refuses to leave an Estate property so that it can be sold.
The Dispute
Sean died in 2022, leaving the residue of his Estate to his three children. His Ottawa home was the Estate’s principal asset. However, his Will did not leave the property to any particular beneficiary or give anyone a right to continue living there.
After Sean’s death, his son Jacob moved into the property with the Estate Trustee’s permission. The beneficiaries were later given an opportunity to purchase the property at fair market value. If no purchase was completed, the property was to be sold, and the occupants were required to leave by August 1, 2024.
No purchase was completed, but Jacob remained in the property. The Estate Trustee therefore sought an order requiring Jacob to leave so that the property could be sold, as well as occupation rent and certain expenses. Jacob opposed the sale and sought to remain in or acquire an interest in the property.
The Court’s Decision
The Court found that Jacob’s entitlement to share in the Estate did not give him a right to the property itself or to continue living there.
Jacob relied, in part, on statements allegedly made by Sean about wanting the property to remain connected to the family. However, relying on Robinson Estate v. Robinson, 2011 ONCA 493, the Court confirmed that a testator’s intentions are determined from the terms of the Will. Sean’s Will did not give Jacob the property, a life interest or a right to occupy it.
The Court also considered whether it should interfere with the Estate Trustee’s decision to sell. While an Estate Trustee must act in good faith and fairly between beneficiaries, the Court found no basis to intervene. The Estate Trustee had obtained an appraisal, given the beneficiaries an opportunity to purchase the property and determined that a sale was required to provide liquidity and complete the administration of the Estate.
Jacob was ordered to provide vacant possession within 60 days.
Occupation Rent
The Court also considered the financial consequences of Jacob remaining in the property after the agreed departure date.
Jacob was ordered to pay occupation rent of $2,900 per month from August 1, 2024 until he left the property. The Court found that he had received the benefit of living in the property without paying rent, while his continued occupation prevented the Estate from selling its principal asset and delayed the administration.
Jacob was also ordered to reimburse $8,275.32 in utility expenses associated with his continued occupation. However, he was not required to pay the property taxes or insurance, which the Court considered ordinary costs of owning the property.
Takeaway
Estate of Craddock confirms an important distinction: a beneficiary’s entitlement to share in an Estate does not necessarily give that beneficiary a right to a particular Estate asset.
Where a Will does not give a beneficiary the right to occupy the deceased’s property, the beneficiary generally cannot prevent the Estate Trustee from selling it simply because they are entitled to a share of the Estate or have a personal connection to the home.
The decision also demonstrates that a beneficiary who continues to occupy Estate property may face financial consequences, including an obligation to pay occupation rent and expenses arising from their continued use of the property.
Thanks for reading!
By Yalda Mostafaie

