Advance Requests for MAID: What Happens When Capacity Is Lost?

Six years ago, I wrote a blog entry about possible changes to Canada’s medical assistance in dying (“MAID”) regime, including whether Canadians might eventually be permitted to make advance requests for MAID to be carried out after losing decision-making capacity. That issue has recently returned to the forefront.

On October 7, 2026, the federal government announced its intention to introduce legislation to decriminalize advance requests for MAID, while leaving it to individual provinces and territories to determine whether to permit them. The issue is particularly significant for individuals diagnosed with conditions such as Alzheimer’s disease and other forms of dementia, who may retain decision-making capacity when diagnosed but anticipate losing it as their illness progresses.

Under the current federal framework, MAID cannot be accessed on the basis of an advance request. Health Canada describes an advance request as one made by a person who still has decision-making capacity with respect to MAID, before they are eligible for or wish to access it, with the intention that MAID be provided in the future after capacity has been lost and specified conditions have been met.

This is different from the existing ability to waive final consent under section 241.2(3.2) of the Criminal Code. In defined circumstances, a person whose natural death is reasonably foreseeable and who has already been assessed and approved for MAID may enter into a written arrangement permitting MAID to proceed if capacity is lost before the agreed upon date. MAID cannot proceed under that arrangement if the person demonstrates refusal or resistance by words, sounds or gestures.

For estates and capacity lawyers, the underlying question is a familiar one: what effect should the law give to wishes expressed while capable after the person becomes incapable? The role, if any, of an attorney for personal care in implementing such wishes will also need to be carefully considered.

Following the recent announcement, Dementia Justice Canada raised concerns about opportunity for coercion, undue influence and elder abuse, particularly where people living with dementia become increasingly dependent upon others.

Courts regularly consider whether wills, powers of attorney, or property transfers have been procured by undue influence and/or during a period of incapacity. Where they have, a remedy may remain available. With an advance request for MAID, there may be no meaningful remedy after the fact. Any new legislative regime will therefore have to grapple not only with capacity and voluntariness when an advance request is made, but also with what happens if the person’s circumstances, conduct or apparent wishes later change.

The recent announcement brings a question that was largely prospective when I wrote about it in 2020 much closer to requiring a concrete answer. We will continue to follow these developments with interest and share updates through our blog.

Thank you for reading,

Nick Esterbauer

Other blog entries that may be of interest:
– What Impact Might MAID Have on a Will Challenge?
– Assessor Independence & Medical Assistance in Dying
– Medical Assistance in Dying: An Overview for Estate Lawyers
– Medical Assistance in Dying: can a third party block an eligible person from accessing MAID?