Some of the most intriguing cases to read are those dealing with missing persons and the administration of their property. In these cases, the courts are forced to examine the circumstances of a person’s disappearance, review the efforts made to find him or her, and declare the person to be dead. The cases read like episodes of a TV drama, full of mystery and suspense. Tragically, they are not fiction.
Prior to 2002, under the common law, no court in Ontario had the jurisdiction to make a declaration death unless it was incidental to a proceeding for some other purpose. Often, this was an application for a grant of probate or administration over the estate of the missing person. Typically, seven years had to have passed since the disappearance before the common law presumption of death could be raised.
In response to the deaths of a number of Canadians in the attacks on the United States on September 11, 2001, the Ontario legislature passed the Declarations of Death Act, 2002.
The Act grants the Superior Court of Justice the power to declare someone to be dead on the application of an interested person. The definition of interested persons is quite broad and includes any person who is or would be affected by an order declaring the person to be dead. The Act specifically lists the missing person’s spouse, next of kin, estate trustee, guardian, attorney for property or personal care, insurer, and others.
A declaration of death is now available not only where a person has been absent for seven years but also where he or she disappeared in circumstances of peril, such as a natural disaster or a plane crash. This allows for faster administration of the estates of persons who very likely died in these occurrences but where no conclusive proof of death is forthcoming.
Whenever the court declares a person to be dead, there is always a hope that the person is in fact alive. The Act contemplates this possibility and provides for the contingency where a person “returns from the dead”. Section 5 of the Act provides that if an individual’s estate trustee has reasonable grounds to believe that the person is not in fact dead, he or she must stop administering the estate. If distributions have already been made pursuant to a judicial declaration of death, they will typically be final and both the beneficiaries and estate trustee are protected. However, the court has the power to order that property be returned to the individual if it is of the opinion that it would be just to do so. Any undistributed property remains the property of the individual, is deemed to be held in trust and will be returned as the court may direct.
Some of these cases have strange facts and even stranger results. Ian Hull recently wrote about the story of Brenda Heist, who resurfaced eleven years after her disappearance. After dropping off her son and daughter at school one morning, she spontaneously decided to join a group of homeless hitchhikers heading to Florida. Stuart Clark has blogged about an incident where an American court refused to reverse a declaration of death despite the “dead” man appearing in court alive.
The Declarations of Death Act, 2002 is a useful tool when a person cannot be located and is probably deceased. It can be used to administer the estate of the missing person, or to deal with the entitlements of a missing beneficiary who is thought to be dead. An application under this Act can be paired with a request for alternative relief under the Absentees Act.
Although grimly fascinating, reported cases under the Declarations of Death Act are relatively rare. Rarer still are cases where someone reappears after a declaration of death. Though they may seem like something out of a mystery novel, sometimes fact is stranger than fiction.
Josh Eisen

